The European Wilderness Society participated in a workshop organised by AGRIDEA in Flims in Graubünden. This mountain village is close to the city Chur and even closer to the well known Calanda Wolfpack. The presence of this wolf pack, and the governmental decision not to change the strict regulations for shooting, has triggered several innovative approaches to protect the livestock of the local farmers and ranchers. Participants (Hunters, shepherds, government and NGO employees) came from the Italian Province of Trentino and South Tyrol, Province of Salzburg and Tyrol, Austria and Bavaria, Germany.
Key to any herd management project is the availability of properly trained herd protection dogs. Alberto, a veterinarian has focuses his life on breeding and training Patou (Pyrennees sheep dog) for the purpose to protect the livestock in a touristic region. The original Patou from the Pyrenees were good for herding of livestock but the first tests showed that they were unpractical in a touristic environment. He has managed to modify the traditional training methods of these dogs to be touristic friendly.
Christian. A local shepherd, asked Alberto for help with protecting his large herd made up of 300 sheep of 8 different sheep breed from up to 19 different farmers. Alberto provides now the dogs free of charge. In addition, Christian is using the standard Swiss electrical mesh fencing systems with 90cm height.
Astrid and Sandra are the two women herding the sheep in the summer between 1500 and 2300 hm. Their main challenge each spring is to get the sheep from different farmers to get along with each other. This seldom last longer than 4 weeks and after that, they can herd the sheep without too much trouble. By that time the sheep are also used to the herd protection dogs and the herd management dogs, which are in Switzerland typically Border Collies.
By trial and error the Ranchers also discovered the lowest threshold on the number of guard dogs needed to protect a herd regardless of the electrical fence. If the number drops below 6 dogs per 400 sheep, the wolves will try their luck.
The local ranchers also showed us wolf proof fences, which were set up in areas where there are no Patou being used. These fences are 1,30 m high and have 5 electrical wires running all around. They are primarily used for cows with calves.
The same is true with herding of cattle. In this case, the guard dogs spend the winter with the cows of one rancher and then meet the cows of the other ranchers on the joint alpine meadow in the spring. The other cows easily adapt to the presence of these large dogs and accepted them as their guard dogs.
Another observation the farmers and AGRIDEA made, was the inability of the livestock and the wild animals to properly see the orange fences. Andreas Schiesser explained how they analyzed at the results along highways to minimize road kills with deer employing blue reflectors and then recommended that farmers should switch their fencing from orange and green to blue.
Summary of this workshop is simple. If ranchers and farmers are keen on protecting their herds and minimizing any losses, several successful best practice examples are available to assist them in their work. In addition, fences need to be supplemented with herd protection dogs to minimize any conflict.
This and several other best practice examples will be featured in our upcoming Herd Management Best Practice Examples from Europe Guidebook too be released this year.